North Haven’s food scene reflects its family-focused and community-driven personality, with restaurants that range from beloved pizza spots to upscale Italian dining. Along Washington Avenue and throughout town, you’ll find cozy, welcoming eateries that keep residents coming back again and again. Dining here is never rushed—it’s about gathering with family, celebrating traditions, and enjoying good food in a relaxed setting. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual slice of New Haven-style apizza, a hearty plate of pasta, or a polished night out with friends, North Haven delivers. The town’s mix of long-standing favorites and newer gems makes it a dining destination in its own right. Here are three local highlights.

Amato’s – A longtime staple offering hearty Italian-American classics, Amato’s is best known for its homestyle pasta dishes, chicken parm, and generous portions. It’s the kind of place where families gather for Sunday dinners and locals celebrate milestones, giving it a reputation as a true North Haven institution.

Bellini’s – Elegant yet approachable, Bellini’s brings authentic Italian cuisine to the heart of town. From house-made pastas to carefully crafted entrees, it offers both refinement and warmth, making it a favorite for date nights, business dinners, and special occasions.

Sergio’s Pizza Restaurant – Famous for its New Haven-style pizza, Sergio’s combines thin, crispy crusts with fresh toppings and friendly service. Beyond pizza, the menu includes grinders, salads, and classic Italian comfort food, making it a go-to for families and take-out nights.